Vocal cord dysfunction: Is it a type of asthma?

Authored by

05 April 2023

Vocal cord dysfunction: Is it a type of asthma? - welzo

Exploring the Differences, Diagnosis, and Management of Vocal Cord Dysfunction

Vocal cord dysfunction (VCD) is a condition often misunderstood and misdiagnosed as asthma due to its similar presentation. The primary distinguishing factor between the two is the location of the airway obstruction: VCD involves the upper airway, while asthma affects the lower airway. Understanding the differences between these two conditions is crucial for accurate diagnosis and effective treatment. This article, written for Welzo.com, the online medical journal, will explore the distinctions between VCD and asthma, elaborate on diagnostic methods, and provide guidance on managing VCD.

Understanding Vocal Cord Dysfunction

Vocal cord dysfunction: Is it a type of asthma?

Definition of Vocal Cord Dysfunction

Vocal cord dysfunction is a condition characterized by the abnormal and paradoxical movement of the vocal cords, particularly during inhalation. This abnormal movement causes narrowing of the airway, resulting in symptoms similar to asthma, such as shortness of breath, wheezing, and coughing Dr. Kenneth W. Altman. However, unlike asthma, VCD does not involve inflammation or constriction of the lower airways.

Prevalence and Impact of Vocal Cord Dysfunction

The prevalence of VCD is difficult to determine due to frequent misdiagnosis as asthma. However, studies suggest that up to 40% of patients with uncontrolled asthma-like symptoms may have VCD [Dr. Christopher E. Randolph]. The misdiagnosis of VCD can lead to unnecessary or excessive asthma treatments, which may not provide relief and could even exacerbate VCD symptoms. Recognizing VCD and distinguishing it from asthma is essential for proper treatment and symptom management.

Causes and Risk Factors of Vocal Cord Dysfunction

The exact cause of VCD remains unclear, but it is believed to be multifactorial, with potential contributing factors including upper respiratory infections, gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), psychological factors, and exposure to irritants or allergens Dr. Peter G. Gibson. Some studies also suggest a possible link between VCD and laryngopharyngeal reflux (LPR), which occurs when stomach acid flows back into the throat, causing irritation and inflammation of the vocal cords Dr. Jamie A. Koufman. Individuals with a history of asthma, anxiety disorders, or vocal cord injury may be at a higher risk for developing VCD.

Differentiating Vocal Cord Dysfunction from Asthma

Clinical Presentation and Symptom Comparison

Although VCD and asthma share similar symptoms, there are subtle differences that can help distinguish one condition from the other. For example, while both conditions may cause wheezing, the wheezing in VCD is typically more prominent during inhalation, whereas in asthma, it is more prominent during exhalation Dr. Sandeep S. Dave. Additionally, VCD symptoms often have a sudden onset and may resolve quickly once the trigger is removed, while asthma symptoms tend to develop more gradually and persist for longer periods.

Diagnostic Methods for Vocal Cord Dysfunction

A thorough medical history, physical examination, and specialized tests can help diagnose VCD and differentiate it from asthma. Common diagnostic methods for VCD include:

Laryngoscopy: A laryngoscopy allows a healthcare provider to visualize the vocal cords directly and assess their movement during breathing. This procedure can confirm the presence of abnormal vocal cord motion indicative of VCD Dr. Michael S. Benninger.
Pulmonary function testing: Spirometry, a common pulmonary function test, can help distinguish VCD from asthma by measuring airflow and lung volumes. In VCD, the flow-volume loop may reveal a flattened inspiratory limb, suggesting upper airway obstruction Dr. James H. Hull.
Imaging studies: Imaging techniques, such as computed tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), may be used to rule out structural abnormalities or other conditions that could mimic VCD symptoms Dr. Rebecca J. Howell.

Managing Vocal Cord Dysfunction

Once VCD is accurately diagnosed, a multidisciplinary approach involving various specialists, including pulmonologists, otolaryngologists, speech therapists, and psychologists, may be necessary to address the multiple factors contributing to VCD. Common management strategies for VCD include:

Speech therapy: Speech therapy can teach individuals techniques to help relax the vocal cords and improve breathing patterns during episodes of VCD. This may include diaphragmatic breathing exercises, vocal cord relaxation exercises, and laryngeal massage Dr. Claudio F. Milstein.

Trigger identification and avoidance: Identifying and avoiding triggers, such as allergens, irritants, or reflux, can help prevent VCD episodes. For instance, individuals with GERD or LPR may benefit from acid-reducing medications, lifestyle modifications, or dietary changes to manage reflux Dr. Robert T. Sataloff. 3. Psychological interventions: Since stress and anxiety can contribute to VCD, psychological interventions, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) or relaxation techniques, can help patients manage their emotions and reduce the frequency and severity of VCD episodes Dr. Gaynor C. I. Smith.

Medications: While medications typically used to treat asthma may not be effective for VCD, certain medications, such as anticholinergics or benzodiazepines, may be prescribed in some cases to relax the vocal cords and ease symptoms Dr. Nicole M. Ryan. However, these medications should be used with caution and under the guidance of a healthcare professional. If you would like to learn more about Asthma check our complete guide to Asthma.

Conclusion

Vocal cord dysfunction is a complex and often misdiagnosed condition that can significantly impact the quality of life for those affected. By recognizing the differences between VCD and asthma, healthcare providers can ensure accurate diagnosis and implement appropriate management strategies. A multidisciplinary approach, including speech therapy, trigger identification and avoidance, psychological interventions, and in some cases, medications, can help improve the lives of individuals living with VCD. As our understanding of VCD continues to grow, it is essential to remain informed about the latest research and advancements in the field to optimize diagnosis, treatment, and patient care.